Trelawny

[Athena Appleton]

Joto!!!!!! Are they prophesies fulfilled? Get with the program, dude!!!

[Jotomicron]

Lol...
I guess they could be... but do we know anything about these shelves, besides the fact that they are black?

[Athena Appleton]

nope, just speculation, really.... there's a reason some are dark and others aren't... since the one that hasn't been fulfilled (that we know of) still had light until it broke, I assume that the ones that don't have light are ones that have been fulfilled...

[Valeria]

She is a myterius person. Harry hates her and he will be very happy if she isn't at school.


Sorry for that terrible English but I#m from Germany

[Athena Appleton]

Harry dislikes her, sure, but I think "hate" is a strong word... first he felt sorry for her for a little while during the whole Umbridge-being-a-female-puppy-dog thing... also, I think after the talk in Dumbledore's office about the prophesies and stuff, he's got a little more respect. Now that he doesn't have to take Divination, I think he'd be perfectly okay with her sticking around...

[Violet]

i dont know how harry will react towards trelawny now. if his attitude stays the way that it was in OoTP then he may blame her for the prophecy.
but if it does change then i think that he will be happy for her to stay around like athena said

[Meg Boyd]

on that note i really hope Harry's attitude gets better, because it would be ashame for him to blame Trelawney for the prohpecy...I mean it isn't her fault, it is just destiny

[Athena Appleton]

nah, i don't think harry'll blame trelawney for the prophesy... he didnt blame her for Voldy coming back...

i hope he gets a better attitude, though, cuz he's an unlikeable little twerp in OotP... Like, I understand, he's gone through more than any 15-year-old should ever have to go through, but I was cheering when Ginny told him he was being stupid over Christmas break, and when Ron and Hermione finally tell him to back off and stop biting their heads off.

[Nobby]

i don't think that Trelawny has a big part to play in the next book. i think harry will drop divination, so i don't think we will see much of her- unless lavender or parvati mention her

[Athena Appleton]

i tend to agree with nobby on this one... with one possible exception. for the last three years, he's felt like divination is all about imagining up fake deaths for yourself... now that he knows that there really are prophesies, it could be that he could want to (or be "encouraged to") continue taking divination to get a better understanding of the prophesies, since there's one about him. i doubt things will happen like that, but it's a possibility.

[Nobby]

That is a possibility! lets just hope harry gets better at divination if he decides to take it!

[hagrid_fang]

I don't think harry will take divination, if he only takes subjects that will get him on the track of being an auror (career advice) i don't think divination was needed

[Athena Appleton]

[quote=hagrid said]I don't think harry will take divination, if he only takes subjects that will get him on the track of being an auror (career advice) i don't think divination was needed[/quote]

not needed, no... I don't think he'll take it either. Just a thought... if he did take it, I think it would be for that reason alone (a deeper understanding of real prophesies). Like I said, though, I don't think he will.

if this posts twice, really sorry... stinky computer.

[Nobby]

Although he hates snape, harry will definately take potions know

[child of darkness]

Potions is one of the only interesting subjects to read about

he shuld definetly carry on