Lord Of The Rings or Harry Potter

[Marcus Baker]

I am going with Harry Potter, sry. I read the Hobbit in 7th grade, and it was a great book. I read the first two of the LOTR series. I didnt like the 1st one that much, and the 2nd one is ok. Im trying to find time to read the 3rd one. But for now, HP is all the way!!!

[Nightfall]

HP and LotR are so different that it's impossible to compare them. The only similarity is that they are both highly popular and epic fantasy novels.
THEY'RE BOTH GREAT!!

[KagomeMIKO]

I LOVE LORD OF THE RINGS im reading all of them i have to much free time im even learning elvish its cool oh and i read the hobbit in 4th grade it was good but not as good as LOTR but harry potter rules to its a tie

[HuffleDuck]

Ah! LotR is great, but the type like me don't read the book but chose to see the movies... The story is pretty nice... I like both of them but somehow Potter still my #1

[AngelicS_89]

I like everything that includes magic and fantasy.I read the Hobit...And the 1st Lotr book,but than I got bored . Anyway I like the movies a lot.3rd is the best.

[KagomeMIKO]

2 ones funnier but i loved the one part were gimli siad "that still only counts as one" right after legalos took down a hole buch of org or trolls on top of the elephant then took down the elephant and slid down his trunk oh and dont forget when there counting how many they killed cause he kept sayin 35 36 37 i started cracking when i herd that

[Scellanis]

lol you sound so much like a movie fan....

those 'elephants' are actually oliphants (according to hobbits) or mumakils if you are elven.....and they are ridden by men from the south....

for those people who don't bother to read the books, you are missing big time on things like Tom Bombadil, Old Man Willow, the Barrow whights, the Scouring of the Shire and the killing of Saruman

Samwise Gamgee has a total of 13 children by the end of the book, Peregrin has one...

anyway im still of the opinion you cant compare them, they are both brilliant....