Broomsticks And Owls

by **Simatra** » Friday 16 March 2007 3:39:37pm

How would that work? James could turn into a stag, not an ugly cat!

by **GodrictheGriffon** » Friday 16 March 2007 6:18:46pm

Where does it say that you can't be both?

by **Run Away!!!** » Friday 16 March 2007 8:08:28pm

I am absolutely certain you can only change into one. And it would make more sense that if anyone was crookshanks it's lily because of the ginger fur and green eyes. But still, thats pretty stupid. And Hagrid was just a random owl bought at the store, not likely to be an animagus.

by **Phoenix in the Ashes** » Saturday 17 March 2007 3:39:53am

You can't have more than one animagus form because you can't choose the form you turn into.

by **youknowwho** » Saturday 17 March 2007 8:58:14pm

Since your animageous reflects your personality, mabye you could have more than one if you have multiple personality disorder. :lol:

by **GodrictheGriffon** » Saturday 17 March 2007 11:23:46pm

That could be it, YKW! Like Snape!
And Hedwig is a girl like Lily and Crookshanks is a boy like James. Hedwig might not have been just some random owl. Hagrid might've boughten her because she reminded him of Lily.
Since when does Lily have ginger hair? :-?

by **FawkesthePhoenix** » Sunday 18 March 2007 1:08:57am

She was a very pretty woman. She had dark red hair and her eyes- her eyes are just like mine, Harry thought, edging a little closer to the glass.

first book, chapt. twelve, pg. 208, paragraph 6, sentence #2.

by **Simatra** » Sunday 18 March 2007 5:14:00pm

Yes thank you, I really think that Run Away's right about if they were animages double, then it's swiched.

by **FawkesthePhoenix** » Thursday 22 March 2007 11:19:43pm

and it's not likely, cuz (sorry for my stupidity if i'm wrong) isn't crookshanks a boy?

by **GodrictheGriffon** » Friday 23 March 2007 1:09:08am

I already said that it doesn't matter!

by **Run Away!!!** » Friday 23 March 2007 7:44:44pm

It doesn't matter because its pretty obvious that neither crookshanks or hedwig are animagus!!!!!!

by **Simatra** » Saturday 24 March 2007 5:12:25pm

Thank YOU, Run Away! Anyway, back of the topic of Rumus being James. I don't think it's really possible but you never know with JKR.
Oh the book that I got this from isn't all like this, they gussed about Mrs. Figg from the beggining. (It was made before O of the P came out.)

by **Quicksilver** » Thursday 7 June 2007 11:01:38pm

I've read some of that book, and some of the theories are quite good, and some are actually true...

But I REALLY dislike this theory. It makes James a dastardly, dowardly creature. Anyway, JKR debunked it awhile ago, thankfully...

by **Simatra** » Friday 8 June 2007 6:06:21pm

Well, that's good to hear. Now I won't have to think about it anymore!

Welcome back, by the way.

Broomsticks And Owls

Remus J. Lupin

Who is online