Moderators: Nightcrawler, Mint, Simatra, Asphodel, Athena Appleton
Gwared wrote:I've re-read every HP book apart from CoS at least three times and as book 5 was the first one I bought I re-read it more (5). Sadly I enjoyed it the first time I read it but it gets more disapointing every read to the point where now on my fifth read through I am extremely dissappointed with it as nothing really happens except Sirius dies and Harry learns his fate. That could've been done in a much shorter book in my opinion.
Charis wrote:Gwared wrote:I've re-read every HP book apart from CoS at least three times and as book 5 was the first one I bought I re-read it more (5). Sadly I enjoyed it the first time I read it but it gets more disapointing every read to the point where now on my fifth read through I am extremely dissappointed with it as nothing really happens except Sirius dies and Harry learns his fate. That could've been done in a much shorter book in my opinion.
maybe you should leave book 5 be for a while... i mean, give it some space. just enjoy it as a story...not analyze it. (not analyze it?!?! I must be insane ) don't read it too much, ot else you'll just get too dissapointed to read it for what it is: a book. well, there we go, my words of wisdom for the day.
hehe
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest