Least Favorite NEW Character After Reading Book 5 (spoilers)

Who do you like best and who could you definately live without? Will there be romance in the air for any of them and who will end up with who?

Moderators: Mistress Siana, Q.Araignee, Scarlet Lioness

Who is your least fave new HP character?

Cho, Ravenclaw
12
9%
Umbridge, "The High Inquisitor"
50
38%
Fudge, the "Minstry of Magic"
11
8%
Bellatrix, "Murderess of Sirius/Death-Eater"
29
22%
Zacharias, Ravenclaw
2
2%
Kreacher, the House Elf
5
4%
Grawp, Hagrid's Brother
8
6%
Luna, Ravenclaw
7
5%
Magorian, the Centaur
1
1%
Marietta, Cho's Friend
3
2%
Other New Character (please post name on the thread)
2
2%
 
Total votes : 130

Least Favorite NEW Character After Reading Book 5 (spoilers)

Postby Lizzy Bennet » Wednesday 25 June 2003 11:35:03pm

I thought it'd be interesting to see who our least favorite NEW characters are after having read book 5 (since there we so many unlikeables! :lol: ) . . . I can't list everyone, so there will be an 'other' choice, but feel free to elaborate on your least favorite on this thread especially if I did not list them! :grin: Why are they your least favorite--who really got on your nerves? I know it'll be a hard choice, but for the poll, you can only vote for one . . . however, you can list several least faves on this thread! :grin: Looking forward to the results! :D

*** When I say new, I mean someone either completely new to the series or someone who hasn't really had a prominent role, but has a bigger role in this book! ***
User avatar
Lizzy Bennet
Angel of Music and Giver of Hugs
 
Posts: 1214
Joined: Monday 2 June 2003 5:35:18pm

Postby Cho Chang » Wednesday 25 June 2003 11:53:41pm

Umbridge. I hate her. She is so annoying. with her "hem, hem" i loved the part where Mcgonagall was offering the throat pills things.

i specially hated Umbridge where she keeps on amending the law. it was annoying.
Cho Chang
First Year Student in Witchcraft and Wizardry
 
Posts: 24
Joined: Wednesday 25 June 2003 11:20:46pm
Location: Canada

Bellatrix

Postby highsorcerer » Thursday 26 June 2003 12:34:17am

Mrs. Lestrange takes the cake. Umbridge was a horrible woman, but her mistake was thinking the ends justify the means. She used horrible means to try and swing Hogwarts into lock-step with the MoM (and in particular, her attempts to discredit Harry Potter), but she apparently was always trying to squash what she thought was an attempt to divide the wizarding world.

Bellatrix, however, is totally evil. Not only was she responsible for Frank and Alice Longbottom, she tried to inflict the same fate on Neville, killed Sirius, and wanted to deal out more pain and death to Harry. It was nice to see that after she underestimated Harry and treated him like a child, Harry was able to get under her skin, both by taunting her about failing Voldemort's mission (I'm sure Harry throughly enjoyed thinking about what was likely to happen to her once she had to admit failure to him), and then hitting her with the Crucious Curse. I rather think she was shocked when she realized she wasn't dealing with a child or student, but a full-fledged wizard. She underestimated him tremendously.

In the end, it would be nice to see Neville get to take her down. I think he's earned the right to do it due to the blood connection (what she did to his parents). Just like Harry will take down the big guy, not only for what he did to his parents, but because it's right.
User avatar
highsorcerer
Department of Mysteries Unspeakable and Registered Animagus (Parrot)
 
Posts: 552
Joined: Monday 23 June 2003 9:28:23am
Location: Area 51 (Headquarters, US Department of Mysteries)

Re: Bellatrix

Postby Lizzy Bennet » Thursday 26 June 2003 12:51:17am

highsorcerer wrote:Mrs. Lestrange takes the cake. Umbridge was a horrible woman, but her mistake was thinking the ends justify the means. She used horrible means to try and swing Hogwarts into lock-step with the MoM (and in particular, her attempts to discredit Harry Potter), but she apparently was always trying to squash what she thought was an attempt to divide the wizarding world.

Bellatrix, however, is totally evil. Not only was she responsible for Frank and Alice Longbottom, she tried to inflict the same fate on Neville, killed Sirius, and wanted to deal out more pain and death to Harry. It was nice to see that after she underestimated Harry and treated him like a child, Harry was able to get under her skin, both by taunting her about failing Voldemort's mission (I'm sure Harry throughly enjoyed thinking about what was likely to happen to her once she had to admit failure to him), and then hitting her with the Crucious Curse. I rather think she was shocked when she realized she wasn't dealing with a child or student, but a full-fledged wizard. She underestimated him tremendously.

In the end, it would be nice to see Neville get to take her down. I think he's earned the right to do it due to the blood connection (what she did to his parents). Just like Harry will take down the big guy, not only for what he did to his parents, but because it's right.


Wow, Highsorcerer, you took the words right out of my mouth! :eek: :grin: I only have a little to add to that. I totally agree about Umbridge, and I, too, voted for Bellatrix as my least fave for all the reasons you mentioned. Kreacher annoyed me, but then House Elves have been manipulated before, and honestly, he seemed to hate Sirius as much as everyone else in Sirius's family hated Sirius (that's just sad, and a whole other topic entirely! :x ).

Certain other characters annoyed me (like Cho, for instance), and like you said (and I agree) Highsorcerer, even as much as Umbridge repulsed (with that horrible detention punishment! :o ) and annoyed me (her little coughs, changing rules at the Ministry, acting all simpering, and totally trashing the professors and students, thinking entirely *too* much of herself, etc.), she wasn't out and out evil and heartless like ol' Bella. :evil: Like you said, Highsorcerer, "she takes the cake" . . . I hope, like you said, Neville gets to do her in with Harry watching, admiringly, on! :mad:
User avatar
Lizzy Bennet
Angel of Music and Giver of Hugs
 
Posts: 1214
Joined: Monday 2 June 2003 5:35:18pm

Postby Fafnul Black » Thursday 26 June 2003 9:59:07am

I would say Luna, not because she is loathable or evil, simply because for me her character is introduced out of nowhere and does not really add to the story. It is more like "oh, let's put a weird girl with big eyes". Future books will tell, but multiplying fancy characters usually does not multiply the interest, and certainly not the clarity ...

OK, I might change my mind, after all Fleur was introduced much the same way, "let's put a nice babe with blond hair", and I'd say it turned out fine :grin:
User avatar
Fafnul Black
Fourth Year
 
Posts: 56
Joined: Monday 23 June 2003 10:19:48am
Location: Knockturn Alley

Postby techjohn » Friday 27 June 2003 3:41:48pm

I had to decide between Bellatrix Lestrange and Umbridge, but voted for Umbridge. Although Lestrange is a really horrible character and killed Sirius, and so on, I really did fing Umbridge much more irritating because of the stuff she did.
User avatar
techjohn
Sixth Year
 
Posts: 97
Joined: Monday 23 June 2003 11:49:43am
Location: The Three Broomsticks, Hogsmeade

Postby Charis » Friday 27 June 2003 11:45:09pm

Bellatrix Lestrange, of course. completely evil. I must say...i rather liked umbridge. not because i thought she was good, or anything, she just made it more interesting. some of my favorite scenes would not have existed if it weren't for umbridge. she also could be rather comical, at times...though in a sinister way. i did not find she was annoying or irritating, just bad. bad as in close to evil, bad.[/i]
User avatar
Charis
Lady of the Lake
 
Posts: 453
Joined: Monday 9 June 2003 10:30:42pm
Location: ohio

Postby molli » Saturday 28 June 2003 12:48:07am

most definitely bellatrix... she is just utterly evil.
User avatar
molli
Third Year Student in Witchcraft and Wizardry
 
Posts: 53
Joined: Saturday 28 June 2003 12:17:56am
Location: Hufflepuff Common Room

Postby Lunatech » Saturday 28 June 2003 2:47:24am

grawp wins this one for me.

where on earth did that come from?!
Lunatech
Fourth Year
 
Posts: 72
Joined: Monday 23 June 2003 10:08:13am

Postby werebane » Saturday 28 June 2003 2:49:00am

i dunno why, but idont like luna
User avatar
werebane
Fully Qualified Wizard
 
Posts: 140
Joined: Tuesday 9 July 2002 1:00:00am
Location: Azkaban

Postby Blaise Zabini » Saturday 28 June 2003 3:01:36am

Cho. Bloody. Chang.

She may not be the most evil, but is definitely one of the most annoying character in the entire series. She was so overly-dramatic, over-sensitive, and just plain idiotic. Honestly, everything was about her and only her. She turned Cedric's death into her own problems and toyed with Harry for her own benefit. Good God, she needs to be the next to die...:x

Oh, and Bellatrix just may be the coolest HP name around. :D
User avatar
Blaise Zabini
Fully Qualified Wizard
 
Posts: 663
Joined: Sunday 27 April 2003 3:05:19pm
Location: The Restaurant at the End of the Universe

Postby Charis » Saturday 28 June 2003 3:23:19am

i duno....nymphadora was pretty cool. :D
User avatar
Charis
Lady of the Lake
 
Posts: 453
Joined: Monday 9 June 2003 10:30:42pm
Location: ohio

Postby HuffleDuck » Saturday 28 June 2003 9:55:12pm

:lol:Yeah Umbridge is really annoying with her stupid new law...But have to admitted, without her there won't be much fun either :grin:
User avatar
HuffleDuck
Keeper of the Lake
 
Posts: 705
Joined: Wednesday 25 June 2003 6:18:28am
Location: Hog's Head and Floo & Blotts

Postby Lizzy Bennet » Saturday 28 June 2003 10:03:21pm

Friendsforever wrote::lol:Yeah Umbridge is really annoying with her stupid new law...But have to admitted, without her there won't be much fun either :grin:


Good point, Friendsforever :)...much as I wanted to strangle her :razz: , she kept you reading with what outrageous/horrible thing she'd do next! :eek: I was cheering anytime anyone "got her back", especially Professor McGonagall! :lol: LOL!
User avatar
Lizzy Bennet
Angel of Music and Giver of Hugs
 
Posts: 1214
Joined: Monday 2 June 2003 5:35:18pm

Postby Blaise Zabini » Sunday 29 June 2003 1:38:08am

Lol, Professor McGonnagall was terrific in the book! I never, ever suspected that she'd be one to break rules or go against authority, but her interactions with Umbridge were great!
User avatar
Blaise Zabini
Fully Qualified Wizard
 
Posts: 663
Joined: Sunday 27 April 2003 3:05:19pm
Location: The Restaurant at the End of the Universe

Next

Return to Characters

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron