Harry Potter vs. Twilght ***SPOILERS***

[hprocks]

what do you guys think of twightlight or do you like harry potter better?
hprocks

[Prisoner of Azkaban]

HP for me, I hate Twilight

[*Riley*]

Proud Potter Nerd

[FawkesthePhoenix]

Pfft. To me, Harry Potter are two completely different entities that cannot compare. Twilight is like a bag of potatoe crisps; Harry Potter is a hearty meal.

[hprocks]

me too,
i am a deffinent a hp fan big time
hprocks

[DucksRMagical]

Harry Potter all the way. I like Twilight, but it's not a series I would reread over and over again like Harry Potter. I have been a proud HP fan for nearly 10 years. During that time, I have read each book numerous times.

I like that comparison, Fawkes.

[hprocks]

thanks,
some of my freinds read the twilght and just wanted to see what all of you think,
like i said before i have been a hp fanfor nearly 3 years this summer and im staying that way.
oh by the way did you know that one of the hp characters from the gof plays a character in the twilight movie
merry christmas
hprocks

[FawkesthePhoenix]

Yup, I did indeed know that Robert Pattinson, who played Cedric, was Edward in Twilight. He was a better wizard than vampire.

[hprocks]

i agree with you he is a better wizard he is just wierd as a vampire!!!

hprocks

[Silver Bunny]

HP for me, I hate Twilight

Same here! twilight's sooo boring. I do like romance, but stephenie meyer overdid it.

[FawkesthePhoenix]

Has anyone here read The Host, Stephenie Meyer's brave attempt at science fiction? It was basically the twilight books condensed into one volume with a different setting and character names.

[Silver Bunny]

Yep, I did read it. In my opinion, The Host was much better than Twilight because Wanda actually kinda likeable. I'm sorry, but I don't like Bella at all because she's hopeless.

[FawkesthePhoenix]

I completely agree, and one of my friends goes insane whenever I say so, but Bella is a terrible character, a classic "damsel in distress" that I cannot stand. Wanda was pretty cool, until she went Bella and started up the sacrificial thinking and losing her common sense. Then my liking for her went down a bit. Melanie's much cooler.

[Silver Bunny]

Melanie's much cooler.

Agreed. And when Wanda got a new body...I just thought that was so stupid!

[hprocks]

hi,
no i didnt read the host
i haven't even heard of it
hprocks