Broomsticks And Owls

by **Fantasy girl** » Tuesday 17 July 2007 4:17:37am

Is Dumbly-dore really dead? Or was that his twin brother impersonating him? No one really saw albus's body except for hagrid, and we all know hagrid woukd lie for dumbly-dore[/i]

by **Simatra** » Wednesday 18 July 2007 3:30:35pm

Yes, but Hagrids not the best actor either.....

I think he's dead.

by **FawkesthePhoenix** » Wednesday 18 July 2007 4:13:05pm

i think he's dead, too. it's all in the phsycology of harry potter. dd had to die because one, harry has to kill voldemort on his own, and two, because they had to have snape kill him to show that even dd makes mistakes sometimes.

by **Run Away!!!** » Wednesday 18 July 2007 11:10:33pm

Hagrid has NEVER been able to keep a secret. And he would never be able to sit back and watch Harry grieve like that, he would have told Harry about their litte secret even if he wasn't supposed to.

by **Simatra** » Thursday 19 July 2007 2:08:48am

Yeah, and Hagrid would be smileing and everything! :lol:

by **zledm007** » Thursday 19 July 2007 4:43:36am

i've only just begun re-reading book six (I'm about a third of the way through), But it seems to me that, as much as I'd like to believe it wasn't Dumbledore that Snape killed, it has to be. By way of the unbreakable vow, had the the person on the other end of Draco's and then Snape's wands not been DD, Snape would not have been forced to kill DD. This is also why I do believe that Snape is, in fact, good, not evil. But that's a topic for another debate.

by **GodrictheGriffon** » Thursday 19 July 2007 4:17:34pm

Wow! I had never really thought of this possibility. I'm going to have to think about it some more. Does he even have a twin brother? Identical, at that?

by **Snow_Crystal** » Friday 20 July 2007 6:43:22pm

He's dead - he has a brother Aberforth and he is the barman at one of the pubs at Hogsmeade - can't remember which one now - I so wanted to be able to read them all again before it came out.

by **GodrictheGriffon** » Friday 20 July 2007 7:48:26pm

I think that it's The Hog's Head. But he can't read.

by **Athena Appleton** » Saturday 21 July 2007 10:56:34am

Fantasy girl wrote:Is Dumbly-dore really dead? Or was that his twin brother impersonating him? No one really saw albus's body except for hagrid, and we all know hagrid woukd lie for dumbly-dore[/i]

What twin brother?

His only brother was at the funeral.

Plus, to assume it was the "twin" instead of him also means the "twin", not Albus, took part in the whole journey prior to the death.

If you're going to have theories, at least give them a solid base.

Broomsticks And Owls

Albus: Dead or Alive

Is Dumbledore really dead?

Albus: Dead or Alive

Re: Albus: Dead or Alive

Who is online