R.A.B

[EFish91]

The second i rad the note that Harry saw in the opened locket which was the fake Horcrux, it hit me exactally what was going on. In the Order of the Phoienix, on Pg. 116.. they were going throught stuff in the Order's hideout. "Their was a heavy locket which no one could open." Their it is, that was the real horcrux! R.A.B is Regulus Black, Sirius' brother! They said he had died 16 years ago, on Voldemort's orders but did not say why he killed him. He found out Voldemort's secret and replaced the locket. Also, the women, i beleive was their sister, after sirius died and the place belonged to Harry, kept on stealing things, including the locket (horcrux).

Another theory i hold is that, Snape, if not already 'dead', i STILL beleive is a goody. It is possible that on DD's orders, snape killed him, as DD felt he was not needed any longer, and Harry would fight VMRT alone. It is also possible that Snape was really DD or that DD was really Snape via Pollyjuice. It is also possible that DD was Slughorn, who knew all about Pollyjuice. It is also possible that Snape was really a DE who was via pollyjuice. Everything, doesn't make sense, because why would Dumbledore plead for Serveus when he "trusted" him so endoudly. ("serveus...please.) There is something missing. It would be quite odd with VDMRT, Harry, Draco, and Snape in book 7, and their will no dought be a twsit, where someone he is using occlumecy, they die early, DD is alive, or something, but number 7 is going to be wicked!

[Snow_Crystal]

Hi EFish

Welcome to the board! Just thought I'd mention there's another feed on the site re RAB so you might want to add your stuff on that one.

Otherwise the site has loads of simultaneous threads..

But welcome and I hope you liked the book

Snow!

[Athena Appleton]

WOW!!!!

I knew immediately it was Regulus Black, especially when I remembered the way he died, but I TOTALLY forgot about the locket!!!!!

So, definately a good thing Harry's still in possession of Sirius's possessions!

[Athena Appleton]

Sorry for the double post:

I think Dumbledore actually died, but unlike Sirius, we'll still hear from DD in the form of his Headmaster portrait, at least.

I do think that Malfoy and Snape are on their ways to death (Malfoy in particular). Wouldn't it stink if Malfoy dies while in a period of wondering if he should cross over to the good side? I think he, like Regulus and others, have realized that while the things Voldemort does could sound heroic or whatever to an evil little punk, the reality is much worse than it seems (i.e. the dark side has lost its glamour)

[thestral]

should this thread not be locked? there's other threads on this in the theories section. sorry, i don't mean to be a wet blanket, but otherwise we're just talking in circles...

[pheonixrising]

how can youi tell regulus is rab what is his middle name anyways

[Ginny Potter]

should this thread not be locked? there's other threads on this in the theories section. sorry, i don't mean to be a wet blanket, but otherwise we're just talking in circles...

I'm not a mod, so I can't lock this thread, but I can post the link to the thread on this very topic that's 7 pages long and very active! Just go here:

http://www.broomsticksandowls.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=118144#118144

Enjoy!

[annachie]

Besides, Harry didn't go dashing across the moors calling "Ginny" in a plaintive voice, which is the impression I get about the love potions effects.

[Ginny Potter]

Besides, Harry didn't go dashing across the moors calling "Ginny" in a plaintive voice, which is the impression I get about the love potions effects.

Are you sure you didn't mean to post that on a different thread, perhaps? This thread is about R.A.B., and as I mentioned above, I concur it should be closed as their is a long thread on it already.

[Mistress Siana]

Yip, there's another pretty active thread in the theories section. Please continue the discussion there so I can lock this one.