Suggestion: discussing the book chapter by chapter

[Broccoli]

Do you think it's a good idea to have separate topics for each chapter of the new book, so that even if people haven't finished the whole book they can express their thoughts on the things they already know? We could also see it as a collective reading!

[Scarlet Lioness]

Yeah that would be a good idea...

[Augusta Longbottom]

great idea! I had been a bit concerned about that...if I'm only on ch.3 I might be tempted to come in here to see what others are saying and they may be at ch. 10 and already know something I don't know yet...so I'm all for the splitting the discussion up by chapter at least until a bit of time has lapsed.

[Tanuki]

Personally, I think that's a bit too fastidius. I think we should just play the forum by ear

[Broccoli]

I don't think that we should keep all the discussions in the chapter-threads only, but for those of us who are afraid to be spoiled but still want to discuss things these threads could be a nice addition.

[fred weasley ;)]

yes that would be very confusing

[niki_192]

i think its pretty good to have seperate threads for each chapter... i was a bit sad with only 607 pages in this book.... i was hoping it would be 1000 but at the moment im only up to chapter 3 and theres already a lot thats happened..... its sooooooo kool!!!!!!!!!!!1
lol

[Gwared]

Personally I think it's a good idea that would draw out some details that get neglected in the general book discussions.

[witherwings]

thats deffinately a great idea! although my sisters run off with the book so I'd have to talk about them from memory...

[crystallised_pineapple]

lol totally understand that my brothers stolen mine.

[Un'Anima Persa]

well, i think it would be difficult to do that, as we would probably be referring to other chapters as well, and somepeople may not have read further and it may get out of hand... so i dont think it would work.

[redhead_723]

I think that would be a good idea, i have finished the book but I know that if I hadn't I would not want to come on here and have the whole thing spoiled for me. I too do not have my book, my sister took it to camp with her, but it is still a good idea.