Moderators: Nightcrawler, Scarlet Lioness, FawkesthePhoenix, Lone_Buck, paintballdecoy
Imelyen wrote:Ummm Snowy...What books are you reading? James didnt pass information to Snape about Lupin and the Whomping Willow...Sirius did that by himself, and it was JAMES who saved him, not Lilly...All Lilly did was stand up for him. And as for any debt owed for that. He repayed it in Harry's first year. And Snape was a Half-Blood, not a muggle-born (Muggle-Borns have no wizarding parentage)
Imelyen wrote:Ummm Snowy...What books are you reading? James didnt pass information to Snape about Lupin and the Whomping Willow...Sirius did that by himself, and it was JAMES who saved him, not Lilly...All Lilly did was stand up for him. And as for any debt owed for that. He repayed it in Harry's first year. And Snape was a Half-Blood, not a muggle-born (Muggle-Borns have no wizarding parentage)
Snowy wrote:I suspect that Lily and Snape had a special bond as a result of this incident, an affinity for both being muggle-borns and therefore became Potions friends. Hence the reason why Lily was so good at Potions.
But on the other hand, could the fact that he's muggle-born be part of the thing that has convinced Dumbledore that he is good?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests