Sirus/Snape

[Seraphine]

I think Head Boy is based on grades though. James and Sirius were described by McGonagall as extreamly talented and smart. Maybe James just had better grades than Remus

I think that in that "triangle" Lupin was an equivalent of Hermione, Ron of Sirius and James of his son... just a comparison...
Sirius and James might have been smart but Lupin must have been even smarter(maybe a swot?). 'Cause you learn more if you're aware that it's a gift that you can study at all (Lupin - thanks to DD).
What James did was very unright, but I agree with Alice - teenage angst.

Seraphine

[Alice I]

Sirius and James might have been smart but Lupin must have been even smarter(maybe a swot?). 'Cause you learn more if you're aware that it's a gift that you can study at all (Lupin - thanks to DD).

I am unfamiliar with the term swot.
What does it mean?

[Seraphine]

A person who studies too hard.

[pallas artemis]

I already felt that James and Sirius probably weren't the nicest most understanding people. Earlier on you get the impression that they're both a little egotistical and eragant. And this memory is Snape's and therefore somewhat exagerated in his own favor. We all prefer to remember things in our favor.

[fred]

i feel diffrent but not in a bad way so i put no. i feel snape got everything he deserved

[Female_alien]

he deserved? as james said, Snape didn't do anything! he was just living in his own world

[fred]

he is a scumbag he deserves to be treated badly

[harrylover]

at first i was a bit shocked but now i think that james and sirius were young...i think they wouldn´t have done it as adults...

[DragonFiend17]

People are different, sometimes more bold around their age, or something, but I still love Sirius. Dearly.

[Tanuki]

Yeah, that was a shock to me as much as it was a shock to Harry! I always thought James and Sirius were this nice great people that would help others when in need....

Oh, they probably did. Egotism and befefaction are two different things. How they feuded with Snape is a whole 'nother matter. He was probably the same foul, greasy, malodious human being that he is now, he just had someone who fought back then. Remember how he acts when he has impunity. I'd say the humiliation might just have been necessary then

[hermione_granger_1993]

Well purposly i think jk did that so that you would say snape is the most agressive meany and that James and serious is the best in the whole world then she turns it around

[Tanuki]

Or maybe, Snape has a very one sided memory and James and Sirius were the people we thought they were before

DD seems to think so

[wildchild123]

I feel quite different about Harry's Dad because i thought that harry's dad was quite a good person at first. I didn't think that he was really arrogant or a complete bully. Sirius was just as bad and lily was right to say no to him at first. But fortunatly lily helped to teach him not to be so arrogant.

[Tanuki]

You can't be a complete bully if you're having a feud. The violence was not one sided. The only difference is that Snape made the mistake of taking on one guy with friends

[Weasleys_gurl07]

i thought that it was quiet rude i thought they were trouble makers but that was cruel even if it was snape