15 Questions

[Mistress Siana]

In a forum for HP fanfiction writers, I posted a few question and got some interesting answers...so I'd like to know your opinion as well.
What do you think:

1) Is Dumbledore a pureblood?
2) Were the Black sisters' marriages arranged?
3) How would Snape feel if Dumbledore died?
4) How many siblings does McGonagall have?
5) Which Hogwarts professor is most likely to have children?
6) Which of the "good" characters will be the first to kill somebody?
7) Do you believe Dumbledore that he sees socks in the mirror of Erised?
8) What is Bellatrix' and Narcissa's relationship like?
9) The marauders' generation had to traitors. Will there be one this time? If yes, who?
10) Who's most likely to be homosexual?
11) Was the ominous Death Eater named Wilkes male or female?
12) Who killed more poeple, Alastor Moody
13) What's Hermione's favourite film?
14) Who of the grown-ups, excluding Hagrid, drinks the most?
15) Imagine the following situation: The Death Eaters suspect that one of them is a traitor, but they have no idea who. In some kind of paranoia, Lucius suspects Narcissa to be the one to give secret information to the Order. How does Bellatrix react? What does Snape do?

[Tanuki]

In a forum for HP fanfiction writers, I posted a few question and got some interesting answers...so I'd like to know your opinion as well.
What do you think:

1) Is Dumbledore a pureblood?
PRobably
2) Were the Black sisters' marriages arranged?
No, they didn't need to. They chose good respectable pureblood marriages of their own bigotry
3) How would Snape feel if Dumbledore died?
He'd probably be devistated since the only person that believed in him is now kaput
4) How many siblings does McGonagall have?
I'd go with 2
5) Which Hogwarts professor is most likely to have children?
McGonnagal
6) Which of the "good" characters will be the first to kill somebody?
Moody, followed by the Weasley twins
7) Do you believe Dumbledore that he sees socks in the mirror of Erised?
I think so, he seems to be a guy who likes simple things
8) What is Bellatrix' and Narcissa's relationship like?
Cold, but aggreeable, as is the case with most snobs
9) The marauders' generation had to traitors. Will there be one this time? If yes, who?
Yes they did, Wormtail. I think Ron might just fight Harry, but not for Voldermort
10) Who's most likely to be homosexual?
Colin Creevy
11) Was the ominous Death Eater named Wilkes male or female?
Male
12) Who killed more poeple, Alastor Moody
13) What's Hermione's favourite film?
Princess Bride
14) Who of the grown-ups, excluding Hagrid, drinks the most?
Lupin, gotta drown the pain somehow
15) Imagine the following situation: The Death Eaters suspect that one of them is a traitor, but they have no idea who. In some kind of paranoia, Lucius suspects Narcissa to be the one to give secret information to the Order. How does Bellatrix react? What does Snape do?

Bellatrix kills her unreasoningly before any truth can be figured out, then promptly kills draco to make sure there wont be any vengance. Snape will report this information to Dumbledore

[Mint]

1) Is Dumbledore a pureblood?
- No

2) Were the Black sisters' marriages arranged?
-Yes

3) How would Snape feel if Dumbledore died?
-shocked, confused, i doubt he would be sad though.

4) How many siblings does McGonagall have?
-none

5) Which Hogwarts professor is most likely to have children?
-eh..Pr.Sprout (sp?) XD

6) Which of the "good" characters will be the first to kill somebody?
-Lupin (Harry out of trio)

7) Do you believe Dumbledore that he sees socks in the mirror of Erised?
-oh yeah. (he probably looses them all the time and has no time to get more)

8) What is Bellatrix' and Narcissa's relationship like?
-I think they are rivals. They pretend to like each other but at the same time want to be better.

9) The marauders' generation had to traitors. Will there be one this time? If yes, who?
-no clue on that one o_o....Snape?

10) Who's most likely to be homosexual?
-Noone I could think of... Snape and Lupin "like" Lilly I think, so they are out and the rest of the teachers...haha i doubt it. Oh wait...whats his name... Lockheart!!

11) Was the ominous Death Eater named Wilkes male or female?
-male

12) Who killed more poeple, Alastor Moody
-Alastor

13) What's Hermione's favourite film?
-she probably doesn’t watch movies, she only reads books

14) Who of the grown-ups, excluding Hagrid, drinks the most?
- excluding…ah darn lol. Um…. Lupin! Or or….Trelawney!

15) Imagine the following situation: The Death Eaters suspect that one of them is a traitor, but they have no idea who. In some kind of paranoia, Lucius suspects Narcissa to be the one to give secret information to the Order. How does Bellatrix react? What does Snape do?

- They both try to get to her to find out if she is really a traitor. (Snape pretending to believe it)

[Phinea Rogue]

1) Is Dumbledore a pureblood?
I think he isn't.

2) Were the Black sisters' marriages arranged?
Yes. It seems like something the purebloods would do.

3) How would Snape feel if Dumbledore died?
I don't know. Sometimes I think he doesn't really like him that much, but it may be because Harry sees it like that. Either he would be sad or... he wouldn't mind that much, but I believe he would be sad.

4) How many siblings does McGonagall have?
Never thought of that one. Maybe none?

5) Which Hogwarts professor is most likely to have children?
*thinks hard* Dumbledore, I've always imagine him as someone who has children.

6) Which of the "good" characters will be the first to kill somebody?
I don't know, anyone in the Order could do it. In defence, of course.

7) Do you believe Dumbledore that he sees socks in the mirror of Erised?
No

8) What is Bellatrix' and Narcissa's relationship like?
Depends on the age difference. I think that Bella is quite older than Narcissa, so it's good, but not very close.

9) The marauders' generation had to traitors. Will there be one this time? If yes, who?
Where? Among the trio? Ron no, neither Hermione... Neville? No. I don't know...

10) Who's most likely to be homosexual?
Lockheart? Lupin?

11) Was the ominous Death Eater named Wilkes male or female?
He's translated into my mother tongue as a male character, so I've always thought of him as of a man.

12) Who killed more poeple, Alastor Moody
or?

13) What's Hermione's favourite film?
No idea. Maybe something like "Sense and Sensibility".

14) Who of the grown-ups, excluding Hagrid, drinks the most?
Mundungus Fletcher?

15) Imagine the following situation: The Death Eaters suspect that one of them is a traitor, but they have no idea who. In some kind of paranoia, Lucius suspects Narcissa to be the one to give secret information to the Order. How does Bellatrix react? What does Snape do?

Bellatrix would go questioning her and Snape... Snape would keep his cover, I believe, waiting what would come out of it.

[Tanuki]

1) Is Dumbledore a pureblood?
I think he isn't.

Malfoy would have brought this up definitely if he weren't. Also, a pureblood who knows his identity is probably the most terrifying thing to Voldermort, which would explain another point of why he's so afraid of Dumbledore. Also, consider his personality. Would a person raised by even one muggle parent be as strange as Dumbledore

2) Were the Black sisters' marriages arranged?
Yes. It seems like something the purebloods would do.

Naw. The way Sirius described it, they went off an married of their own accord. It would also explain how Andromeda managed to marry Fred Tonks and not to arranged groom. These people knew enought to program their kids with enough bigotry to pick their own pureblood grooms... and if they didn't, they were out of the family

3) How would Snape feel if Dumbledore died?
I don't know. Sometimes I think he doesn't really like him that much, but it may be because Harry sees it like that. Either he would be sad or... he wouldn't mind that much, but I believe he would be sad.

Ditto. Dumbledore is the only one who believes in Snape

4) How many siblings does McGonagall have?
Never thought of that one. Maybe none?

I'd say at least one. Only children are kind of spoiled, and McGonagall has a very "harsh big sister" attitude

5) Which Hogwarts professor is most likely to have children?
*thinks hard* Dumbledore, I've always imagine him as someone who has children.

I'd have to say McGonagall, but I wouldn't want to meet her kids

6) Which of the "good" characters will be the first to kill somebody?
I don't know, anyone in the Order could do it. In defence, of course.

Moody's paranoid enough, and enough people are probably out to get him

7) Do you believe Dumbledore that he sees socks in the mirror of Erised?
No

Why not, consider his personality. He's not a very complex guy

8) What is Bellatrix' and Narcissa's relationship like?
Depends on the age difference. I think that Bella is quite older than Narcissa, so it's good, but not very close.

9) The marauders' generation had to traitors. Will there be one this time? If yes, who?
Where? Among the trio? Ron no, neither Hermione... Neville? No. I don't know...

10) Who's most likely to be homosexual?
Lockheart? Lupin?

11) Was the ominous Death Eater named Wilkes male or female?
He's translated into my mother tongue as a male character, so I've always thought of him as of a man.

12) Who killed more poeple, Alastor Moody
or?

13) What's Hermione's favourite film?
No idea. Maybe something like "Sense and Sensibility".

She likes rules, but she went idiotically ga-ga over Lockheart, which means she IS a girl. I'd say the Princess Bride is closer

14) Who of the grown-ups, excluding Hagrid, drinks the most?
Mundungus Fletcher?

15) Imagine the following situation: The Death Eaters suspect that one of them is a traitor, but they have no idea who. In some kind of paranoia, Lucius suspects Narcissa to be the one to give secret information to the Order. How does Bellatrix react? What does Snape do?

Bellatrix would go questioning her and Snape... Snape would keep his cover, I believe, waiting what would come out of it.

[Mistress Siana]

Hm...interesting! Thanks for answering

No 12 meant: who killed more people, Alastor Moody or Lucius Malfoy. I don't know where the rest went.

My guesses are

1) Is Dumbledore a pureblood?
yes

2) Were the Black sisters' marriages arranged?
-Yes

3) How would Snape feel if Dumbledore died?
-I'd say he'd be sad, and angry

4) How many siblings does McGonagall have?
-3, 2 brothers and 1 sister

5) Which Hogwarts professor is most likely to have children?
-McGonagall

6) Which of the "good" characters will be the first to kill somebody?
-Lupin, Hermione or Snape

7) Do you believe Dumbledore that he sees socks in the mirror of Erised?
-I believe he does but there's a deeper meaning to it than we think

8) What is Bellatrix' and Narcissa's relationship like?
-I think Bellatrix thinks of her sister as a kind of weak trophy wife

9) The marauders' generation had to traitors. Will there be one this time? If yes, who?
-no clue

10) Who's most likely to be homosexual?
-Voldemort (and I'm serious)

11) Was the ominous Death Eater named Wilkes male or female?
-female

12) Who killed more people, Alastor Moody or Lucius Malfoy?
-Moody

13) What's Hermione's favourite film?
-Uncle Tom's hut? Dunno...

14) Who of the grown-ups, excluding Hagrid, drinks the most?
- excluding…ah darn lol. Um…. Lupin! Or or….Trelawney! <--I like that answer!

15) Imagine the following situation: The Death Eaters suspect that one of them is a traitor, but they have no idea who. In some kind of paranoia, Lucius suspects Narcissa to be the one to give secret information to the Order. How does Bellatrix react? What does Snape do?

- Bella would maybe go against her, Snape would go and brew Veritaserum

[Phinea Rogue]

2) Were the Black sisters' marriages arranged?
Yes. It seems like something the purebloods would do.

Naw. The way Sirius described it, they went off an married of their own accord. It would also explain how Andromeda managed to marry Fred Tonks and not to arranged groom. These people knew enought to program their kids with enough bigotry to pick their own pureblood grooms... and if they didn't, they were out of the family

Yes, Andromeda married Fred, but also got disowned (she's not on the gobelin), so I wouldn't say that they're so free in their choices. I believe that parents have a lot to say about marriages. Of course, some of them (Andromeda) may rebell and go to marry someone whom the family doesn't approve of.

Voldemort as a homosexual? Interesting thought, Mistress Sianna. Why do you think so?

[Mistress Siana]

Can't really say why, it's just a feeling, something about the way he talks. I don't think he'll be revealed as one, though.

[Nightcrawler]

In a forum for HP fanfiction writers, I posted a few question and got some interesting answers...so I'd like to know your opinion as well.
What do you think:

1) Is Dumbledore a pureblood?

Yeah, I think he is. He's a bit wierd for me to think he was muggle raised and the wizarding comnunity holds him in very high esteem.

2) Were the Black sisters' marriages arranged?

I can see how such a thing may be possible, but I dont think so. For a comnunity of people with such smallminded ideals such as the anti-mugglism, it is surprising how both men and women seem to be given equal rights. So I don't think marriages were arranged.

3) How would Snape feel if Dumbledore died?

I think that Snape would be devistated. I'd go as far as to say that if this happened he would go on a vengeful suicide mission and would mannage to kill quite a few Deatheaters before being defeated.

Although Snape often disagrees with Dumbledore's decisions, and Snape does not seem like a person who is good aat expressing emotions, I believe that he consideres Dumbledore to be like a father, and deeply respects him. Dumbledore is the only one who trusts Snape enough to give him a second chance.

4) How many siblings does McGonagall have?

I don't think she has any. But that's just me.

5) Which Hogwarts professor is most likely to have children?

hmmm.... none of them really seem like the sort to raise thier own kids, or even get married for that matter. Still, I'm sure there is a woman out there who finds Proffesor Flitwick absolutly charming..... (sorry).

On second thoughts, I can imagaine Hagrid with a familly, or even Ronan.

6) Which of the "good" characters will be the first to kill somebody?

I think Snape would have no problem killing someone if he were forced to.

7) Do you believe Dumbledore that he sees socks in the mirror of Erised?

No. In fact I believe there is even a line in the book that suggests he is lying. I'll have to go and check later though.

8) What is Bellatrix' and Narcissa's relationship like?

I'd imagaine they get along pretty well. They have common goals and ideals.

9) The marauders' generation had to traitors. Will there be one this time?

Is this the trio or the Order? If the trio... no. Perhaps Ron would be tempted, but ultimetly he's a good guy. I think it would be interesting if there were a traitor in the Order, but I don't know who it could be.

10) Who's most likely to be homosexual?

Possibly Snape? Maybe that is yet another reason why he feels isolated and bitter.

11) Was the ominous Death Eater named Wilkes male or female?

I can't even remeber who we are talking about The name sounds male to me.

12) Who killed more poeple, Alastor Moody or Lucius Malfoy?

I think that Moody would have killed more people directly (he is an auror after all) but Lucius Malfoy would have killed more people indirectly (through giving orders and manipulation).

13) What's Hermione's favourite film?

I think that she secretly watches Jackass and South Park.

14) Who of the grown-ups, excluding Hagrid, drinks the most?

Mundungus Fletcher or Winky

15) Imagine the following situation: The Death Eaters suspect that one of them is a traitor, but they have no idea who. In some kind of paranoia, Lucius suspects Narcissa to be the one to give secret information to the
Order. How does Bellatrix react? What does Snape do?

Bellatrix laughs it off and makes it clear how rediculus Lucius is being. Nobody really believes Lucius, but because Snape does not want to get caught out, he supports Lucius. Snape would later plant some sort of "evidence" on Bellatrix so that she gets "found out". Then he could relax a little because the Deatheaters would think they have found thier "traitor".

[Nightcrawler]

lol I read that last question wrong. I thought you meant that Lucius suspected Bella to be the traitor. If he suspected Narcissa to be the traitor, I doubt he would say anything.


And while it is an interesting idea to contemplate, I doubt any of the characters will be revealed to be homosexual. Just imagine how much Christian fundimentilests would hate JKR if she did that!

And I can kinda see where you are comming from Miss Siana about Voldermort. Has anyone else noticed that evil characters tend to be more accepting of differing sexualities? I guess that is one area where villians seem to be ahead of society.

[DragonFiend17]

In a forum for HP fanfiction writers, I posted a few question and got some interesting answers...so I'd like to know your opinion as well.
What do you think:

1) Is Dumbledore a pureblood?
2) Were the Black sisters' marriages arranged?
3) How would Snape feel if Dumbledore died?
4) How many siblings does McGonagall have?
5) Which Hogwarts professor is most likely to have children?
6) Which of the "good" characters will be the first to kill somebody?
7) Do you believe Dumbledore that he sees socks in the mirror of Erised?
8) What is Bellatrix' and Narcissa's relationship like?
9) The marauders' generation had to traitors. Will there be one this time? If yes, who?
10) Who's most likely to be homosexual?
11) Was the ominous Death Eater named Wilkes male or female?
12) Who killed more poeple, Alastor Moody
13) What's Hermione's favourite film?
14) Who of the grown-ups, excluding Hagrid, drinks the most?
15) Imagine the following situation: The Death Eaters suspect that one of them is a traitor, but they have no idea who. In some kind of paranoia, Lucius suspects Narcissa to be the one to give secret information to the Order. How does Bellatrix react? What does Snape do?

1) Probably, hard to say...
2) I think that they married them for approval from parents
3) He would jump for joy!!!
4) She might be the last of five or so...hey, im trying!!!
5) Sprout seems the more house-holdy type...least of all snape. XP
6) Harry--well he kind of has to kill Voldemort in the end
7) NO i believe he sees harry safe with him becuase we now know he loves him
8) sisters
9) no
10) well on www.potterpuppetpals.com they kind of make fun of all the characters (lol) but i dunno...none of them act it, because of the Yule Ball i cant make accusations...
11) male, wasnt it?
12) malfoy--he was a death eater, his JOB was to kill.
13) hmm well she should have one seeing she is muggle-born.. interesting, probably a documentary !!! lol, of the ones today...well the genre would be like mystery so maybe she liked the scooby doo movies!!
14) WOW...where did that come from???...umm...*brightening* I KNOW!!! you know that guy wrapped up in those bandages?? umm i 4got his name but in the fifth book he was drinking the red stuff...he was the one causing all the trouble with the muggles who was let off because he spied on harry and friends and the boar's head!!!
15) wow...eerm...okay, narcissa tells the order and bellatrix--she's the death eater that finds out? umm she would tell voldemort(who would question her, torture her and give her Veritaserum to tell if she was speaking truthfully) and if snape found out...he would....either pretend he hadnt heard, tell dumbledore to stay on his good side, or turn narcissa in to voldemort and re-join the death eaters.

ah well, i tried

[Un'Anima Persa]

In a forum for HP fanfiction writers, I posted a few question and got some interesting answers...so I'd like to know your opinion as well.
What do you think:

1) Is Dumbledore a pureblood?
2) Were the Black sisters' marriages arranged?
3) How would Snape feel if Dumbledore died?
4) How many siblings does McGonagall have?
5) Which Hogwarts professor is most likely to have children?
6) Which of the "good" characters will be the first to kill somebody?
7) Do you believe Dumbledore that he sees socks in the mirror of Erised?
8) What is Bellatrix' and Narcissa's relationship like?
9) The marauders' generation had to traitors. Will there be one this time? If yes, who?
10) Who's most likely to be homosexual?
11) Was the ominous Death Eater named Wilkes male or female?
12) Who killed more poeple, Alastor Moody
13) What's Hermione's favourite film?
14) Who of the grown-ups, excluding Hagrid, drinks the most?
15) Imagine the following situation: The Death Eaters suspect that one of them is a traitor, but they have no idea who. In some kind of paranoia, Lucius suspects Narcissa to be the one to give secret information to the Order. How does Bellatrix react? What does Snape do?

1) i always thought that he was halfblood or less...
2)i believe so
3)oddly befuddled, maybe sad, because inside, i think he's just a big softy!
4)i dont rememberit saying, but i would think a lot... that, or her parents kneew not to spoil her.
5)probably binns... lol j/k... i think it would be lupin... well... he really isn't a professor though...
6)MOST DEFINITELY sirius, because i still firmly believe that he is alive.
7)lol!
8)They probably dont talk much... i think that they hate each other.
9)yes, snape. if you mean trio, yes, hermy
10)viktor krum
11)female
12)or who??
13)some educational cr*p no doubt...
14)moody
15)bellatrix kills narcissa, and snape laughs while she does it...

those are my opinions...

[Un'Anima Persa]

oh, sorry, didnt see the lucious (sp?) part... prolly moody... he just seems like a murderer to me... lol

[DragonFiend17]

they both kinda are murderers...but lucius enjoys it....

[Un'Anima Persa]

well i know they r both murderers, but moody just strikes me more as the murdering type... lucious is a death eater... what do you expect?