Scar is a Horcrux!?

[GodrictheGriffon]

There is arumor going around some other forums that Harrry's scar is a horcrux and that he will have to figure out a way to destroy his forehead without killing himself. What do you think about that? I bet it's rubbish because if that were true then Voldemort would have been able to touch Harry"s scar without crumbling. There's another rumor that his whole body is a horcrux. I want to see him try and destroy himself why'll still fulfilling the prophecy. Not that I want him to die, though!

[Simatra]

*blink blink* Yeah, that is stupid.


Now if LV was going to make a Horcrux by killing him, that's understandable.

[Run Away!!!]

I think Voldy most definitely would have made all the horcruxes before he tried to kill Harry.

[Scellanis]

Possibly he could have been using Harry's death for the last horcrux but since Harry's death didn't work then I suspect any horcrux it should have made wouldn't have worked either so either all the horcruxes were made before or he'd have one less than he intended....unless Harry is a horcrux but that would be a bit silly. Suppose it depends on whether living things can be horcruxes and even then how it would affect something with as much intelligence as a human.

[FawkesthePhoenix]

voldie did intend to use harry as his last horcrux.

[Scellanis]

Yeah but the process of making a horcrux requires the person who shall die plus the object the horcrux will go in, if Harry was the person who shall die then something else in the room must have been the object because he didn't intend to kill Lily and he killed James before he got in the room. So the only way Harry or his scar could be a Horcrux is if the horcrux spell also backfired but then that could explain why Harry can speak parseltongue I suppose. If a bit of Volde is actually stuck inside him due to the hocrux spell going wrong then it would explain how he got some of Volde's powers...but would that still count as a horcrux?

[Simatra]

It's some kind of off brand!
I really don't know how that'd would I imagin that not much is know about Horcrux if they go wronge, concidering that they're not done that often.

[GodrictheGriffon]

Maybe that's why Harry survived and Lord Voldemort somewhat destroyed! Lord Voldemort hadn't made his Seventh Horcrux yet!
Holy cr*p I just answered The-Unanswered-Question-That-Might-Have-Been-Unanswerable!

[Simatra]

Anyone could guess that...
I'd really don't think that Harry's scar is a Horcrux, the only why that would work is if Harry destoryed all the Horcrux's then killed LV, and than killed himself. And that would stink.

[Run Away!!!]

Why on earth would LV want to make Harry a horcrux???? And we already know the curse he used to try and kill harry.

[GodrictheGriffon]

I know that. But that's why it almost destroyed hm!

[Run Away!!!]

I never understand what you are saying half the time! It was Harry's mothers love for him that almost destroyed LV, not LV trying to turn Harry into a horcrux. LV wanted to kill Harry and get rid of him, not put part of himself there.

[FawkesthePhoenix]

Yeah but the process of making a horcrux requires the person who shall die plus the object the horcrux will go in, if Harry was the person who shall die then something else in the room must have been the object because he didn't intend to kill Lily and he killed James before he got in the room. So the only way Harry or his scar could be a Horcrux is if the horcrux spell also backfired but then that could explain why Harry can speak parseltongue I suppose. If a bit of Volde is actually stuck inside him due to the hocrux spell going wrong then it would explain how he got some of Volde's powers...but would that still count as a horcrux?

when you kill someone, your soul rips in half and it stays in your body. a different spell is used to put the peice of your soul into an object, or else almost every single DE would have (a) horcrux(es).

[GodrictheGriffon]

But LV not having all Seven Horcruxes certainly helped.

[Simatra]

I don't think that Harry's scar has anything to do with the Horcrux, LV wouldn't wait for all the Horcrux to be done before trying to kill his only real threat.