Scar is a Horcrux!?

[Run Away!!!]

Everything he says is completely fake, its obviously not correct. Somebody had probably written a whole book in their version, not JK's.

Besides, on with this discussion, we know that we can trust everything DD says, and he tells harry that LV was going to create his last horcrux with Harry's death. Therefore, it is silly to assume that harry IS the horcrux. The last horcrux (Nagini) was created when LV killed the old muggle man years later.

[Mr.Potter]

u eat ur words when the book is released
n by the way u shud read half-blood prince a little closely

dumbledore himself said he they can rule out nagini

n the one he used when arthur weasley was attacked, the green smoke within it represents harry's sould n dumbledore said himself y soul is divided

u'l knw this also in the deathly hallows
no one believes me now

but u'l when its released so im not at all hurt

just wait till the book is released
so long, bye

[Simatra]

Run Away said:

Everything he says is completely fake, its obviously not correct. Somebody had probably written a whole book in their version, not JK's.

Besides, on with this discussion, we know that we can trust everything DD says, and he tells harry that LV was going to create his last horcrux with Harry's death. Therefore, it is silly to assume that harry IS the horcrux. The last horcrux (Nagini) was created when LV killed the old muggle man years later.

I think that it being the Horcrux is a stupib idea. And whoever said that Harry will make a horcrux so that he won't die, is a sick-o.

[Run Away!!!]

u eat ur words when the book is released
n by the way u shud read half-blood prince a little closely

dumbledore himself said he they can rule out nagini

Ok I read the HBP yesterday and I know DD did not rule out Nagini. He's the person that said it WAS Nagini.

[GodrictheGriffon]

Nope. Harry never wants to make a Horcrux and I'm on J.K. Rowlings site at the moment, to a she said that they will not merge and thus will niether be made into a Horcrux for the other. And what about all of the Horcruxes already done. Where were the lightning shapes on those?

[selene]

i don't think there was a lightning shape thingy on the ring, a very ugly curse, yes but no lightning shape
and it makes sense that nagini is a horcrux, but was he strong enough to do it at that point?

[FawkesthePhoenix]

maybe somehow wormtail did it for him?

[selene]

i don't know
and the more i think about, the less likely it seems, voldy doesn't trust wormtail that much, telling him about the horcruxes doesn't seem like something he would do, much less telling or even teaching wormtail how to do it.
even if the deatheaters know about the horcruxes, he wouldn't want them to know how to make them, right?

[youknowwho]

Even if voldy did tell any the deatheaters about the horcruxes(which I highly doubt that he did) Would you be able to nake a horcrux for someone else anyway?

[Run Away!!!]

I don't think so. Well we know that whatever Mr Potter has said on this matter is false so disregard anything he said about lightning shaped marks or anything like that.
DD himself said that Nagini was the last horcrux and not Harry.

[Phoenix in the Ashes]

Interesting how you call it the last horcrux, when we don't actually know the one "before" it. I suppose it's because the others are grouped together - something of Slytherin's, something of Hufflepuff's, so we assume the other one (or two? Can't really remember) will be something else that belonged to the founders, and we call Nagini separate.

Or of course you could be referring to the order in which they were made.

But I like to think in terms of the order in which they were found by Harry and the crew.

I suppose by later consideration you said it was last because it was the last one made...

But hey. Not gonna delete all this. It's an okay point .

[Run Away!!!]

Well yes I was referring to it as being the last one made, and we know what all the others are so my point is that Harry is not a horcrux because DD named them all for us. Apart from the mysterious object of Gryffindors or Ravenclaws which we do not know exactly what it is, but we do know its not Harry!

[Phoenix in the Ashes]

Yes well, we don't know what all of them are, because as you say we don't know what the mysterious object of Gryffindor or Ravenclaw is.

It could be something very obscure... which makes it different and very much unknown.

But whatever, in terms of the scar itself being a horcrux, I think it's rubbish. It wouldn't be the scar itself anyway... it would be Harry if it were anything. And it's not. In my opinion anyway...

[Alexandra]

Can anyone tell me what is with this Mr.Potter? Why was he banned? I don't get it!!

[FawkesthePhoenix]

he claimed he already read the 7th book, and he admitted he couldn't get the book legally, so paul banned him.

i don't think harry's scar is a horcrux. i don't think you can make one part of someone/something a horcrux, you'd have make the whole thing a horcrux.