Broomsticks And Owls

by **threejjj** » Monday 8 August 2005 5:33:13pm

When I was reviewing the books I realized something. We know the in first year Harry took a boat with the rest of the first years to get to school. In second year the flying car. Now in third year he was able to ride a carriage to the school, and if his mother died in front of him like book one said then shouldn't he have seen the horses in his third year? ( I can remember the name of those things)

by **Person1** » Monday 8 August 2005 6:14:16pm

heh, yeah shoulda seen threstral, but who says he didn't?

by **Scellanis** » Monday 8 August 2005 6:19:52pm

Maybe you can only see them if you can remember seeing the person die....he obviously can't.

by **threejjj** » Monday 8 August 2005 6:19:59pm

I think you have to read book 5, chapter ten, page 196 to see what I mean.

by **Un'Anima Persa** » Monday 8 August 2005 6:28:13pm

MAYBE: aunt petunia is really a witch who got her wand revoked coz she did something awful the night harry's parents dies but she erased his memory so he dont remember it and he cant see the thestrals and petunia wants her wand so she hates the ministry?

yea.... riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight.....

by **Person1** » Tuesday 9 August 2005 4:11:40am

Umm....where did that come from?

by **Un'Anima Persa** » Tuesday 9 August 2005 4:14:22am

trying to explain y harry couldnt see thestrals...

by **Phoenix in the Ashes** » Tuesday 9 August 2005 6:16:16am

JKRs webdite explained, or did anyway. I remember reading why somewhere.

by **Nightcrawler** » Tuesday 9 August 2005 7:04:13am

I'm going to close this thread because there's already a similar discusion (and identical post) in the "just one question" thread. Feel free to continue the discussion there.

Broomsticks And Owls

THEN WHY????

THEN WHY????

Who is online