Broomsticks And Owls

by **Tween_Luv** » Friday 15 April 2005 5:31:38am

I admit that Cho seems over - dramatic and all that. but, really...she has a right to be. What would you do if your girlfriend/boyfriend died, and then you started dating the person who saw them die? I doubt anyone has experienced this, but...its probably really nervwracking, and not even probably, definately. I can imagine why Cho acted that way, and i actually think that she could have acted much much much worse than that, i know many other girls would have behaved worse than her if they had the same experience.

by **Weasleys_gurl07** » Tuesday 31 May 2005 8:31:12pm

i hated umbrdge she drove me crazy! she was just cruel

by **thestral** » Wednesday 1 June 2005 11:40:56am

actually in a in a really horrible way i though umbridge was one of the best characters in OotP. annoying, evil and cruel yes. but so well written i loved all the little touches like her "hem hem" and her constant description of being toadlike. obviously you don't like her but she was a really good villain and i thought most of her bits, paticularly with mcgonagall were hilarious. i detested her obviously but you enjoyed hating her, just to see her get her comuppence. :lol:

(that's evil laughter by the way)

i actually found grawp to be a bit dry and boring, i like hagrid but i often find the hagrid storylines like norbert in P/S and you know his scrapes and stuff,, if they go on for too long, i switch off so i didn't really like the grawp storyline, although it will obviously have some significance to the plot in further books and will affect the outcome of the war in some way, i predict anyway.

by **Ravenclawsweety** » Wednesday 22 June 2005 5:04:27pm

Ok, whoever thought Bellatrix was bad in book 5, u r weird, she is awesome!!!!! Ok, dont get a wrong impression, but she was awesome, i hate the most James and Sirius for doing that to Snape :grin:

by **Tanuki** » Wednesday 22 June 2005 6:34:18pm

Snape deserves it... he always does

by **Un'Anima Persa** » Wednesday 22 June 2005 6:43:01pm

I think umbridge... Because even though sirius is dead, harry has his friends at hogwarts. if umbridge took hogwrs away, then who knows what he'd do!

by **Ravenclawsweety** » Wednesday 22 June 2005 8:49:20pm

Snape didint deserve it, duh, it was James's fault he is the way he is now, tsk tsk tsk

by **Tanuki** » Thursday 23 June 2005 3:27:02am

Don't blame it on James, Snape got to where he is based on his own decisions. No one can place blame anywhere save with themselves for their actions

Website · by **ellenmay** » Thursday 23 June 2005 3:35:16am

I hated Umbridge, but I loved that she was in the story. JKR made us hate Umbridge on purpose...so we would sympathize with our heroes.
When her actions were unfair towards the students, I felt that she was acting against me. I loved her part in the story, but I hated her. Her part was great.

by **Scarlet Lioness** » Thursday 23 June 2005 7:56:14am

I really couldn't stand Grawp because that whole story about Hagrid going to the Giants was really boring and dragged on for sooo long...

One of my favourite characters was Umbridge because it gave Harry and the rest of them someone to worry about...
It was also funny when she was doing the inspections!!! :grin:

by **Nikki** » Saturday 25 June 2005 4:51:20pm

lets see, Umbridge, Sirius, and James

by **thestral** » Sunday 26 June 2005 10:21:21am

sirius is among your LEAST favourite characters?!? :eek:

please do not disrespect the dead, myself and many others are still in mourning. sirius was the best character out of all of them. do not blacken his name (black, get it?:grin:) and james what did he ever do to you?

by **sirius_lives_forever** » Thursday 30 June 2005 7:42:14pm

i hated umbridge!!!! during every scene with her in it i just wished i was in the book so i could punch her lights out!!

by **sirius_lives_forever** » Thursday 30 June 2005 7:43:44pm

how can you hate sirius and james??? :cry:

you like snape dont you.....

by **Tanuki** » Tuesday 5 July 2005 2:40:21pm

Let's face it, the general public are so hard to please, and so easy to sway; especially when yoiu want them to hate someone. They'll only accept a perfect, unflawed James. After all, he's supposed to be a good guy, and good guys are not supposed to hate anyone and take advantage of that hate. James was supposed to remain a paragon of virtue forever, even though he was only fifteen. I mean, it's so easy to ignore the fact that he and Snape had been Feuding for years; or Snape's character traits make him easy to dislike, or the fact that he in fact saved said Snape not a year later I believe, or the other good he's done; the public only cares about a few pages of action. All the other work J.K.R. did to make us respect James before and after those pages is meaningless in their eyes. I mean, it's not like Fred and George have done the same thing

Broomsticks And Owls

Least Favorite NEW Character After Reading Book 5 (spoilers)

Who is your least fave new HP character?

Who is online