Broomsticks And Owls

by **Meg Boyd** » Wednesday 1 September 2004 2:46:51pm

they kill in a way that humans cannot, and i'm not sure i have ever seen them cast a spell. maybe they do, i haven't noticed it. I am still thinking that they might just be dead....unable to feel love and compassion...not human

by **niki_192** » Saturday 9 July 2005 12:59:05pm

i rekon dementors are not alive coz remember j.k said that dementors are "soulless" creatures and technically if ur soulless u don't live

by **Tanuki** » Saturday 9 July 2005 3:22:37pm

You can live without a soul.

by **Nikki** » Saturday 9 July 2005 9:25:30pm

When did they say u can live without a soul? Anyway are people made dementors by birth or do they choose to be one?

by **niki_192** » Sunday 10 July 2005 9:59:09am

just my opinion.....j.k said u can't live without a soul aswell....somewhere on t.v she commented on dementors or somethin...anyway can't remember

by **niki_192** » Sunday 10 July 2005 10:00:41am

oh and btw a soul....if it comes out of u...ur dead.... a soul is u...thats y wen u die ur soul comes out...

by **Nikki** » Sunday 10 July 2005 5:39:51pm

yea i know that u cant live w/out one, tell that to Tanuki

by **Tanuki** » Monday 11 July 2005 12:58:23am

REad prisoner of Azkaban young ones... you'd be surprised by what you read. Of course, you two appear to need to learn to read in general

by **Un'Anima Persa** » Monday 11 July 2005 1:48:23am

I didnt vote... than again... i really dont know. I think they are between life and death.. like immortality or somwthinhg, like the effect unicorn's lood has on ppl, barely there, but i dont think they're unhappy.. or maybe they r ppl who live really bad lives and they want to make others suffer as well... but they could be their own species... like were never human... i need to think abou this more... im confuzzled!!! :???:

by **Scarlet Lioness** » Monday 11 July 2005 1:52:56am

DorkWad547?! wrote:I didnt vote... than again... i really dont know. I think they are between life and death.. like immortality or somwthinhg, like the effect unicorn's lood has on ppl, barely there, but i dont think they're unhappy.. or maybe they r ppl who live really bad lives and they want to make others suffer as well... but they could be their own species... like were never human... i need to think abou this more... im confuzzled!!!

Don't worry I'm really confused about death eaters too...They're nor dead nor alive it seems... :grin:

by **pheonixrising** » Monday 1 August 2005 2:46:36am

dementors have no soul lupin said therefore they do not live his logic woprks for me

Broomsticks And Owls

The Dementors

Are dementors 'alive'?

Who is online