Broomsticks And Owls

by **Ginny Malfoy** » Sunday 11 January 2004 10:25:56pm

...signed up for so many classes in her second year that she needed a time-turner in her third year?

A lot of book 3's crucial events hinged on that time-turner and knowing how to use it...what would it have affected? Also, what classes might Hermione have chosen to take and declined not to take (definitely Divination! :lol:

)?

by **Marcus Baker** » Thursday 15 January 2004 1:49:03pm

Well, this is intresting. I first think that she would only sign up for Arithmancy (since it was the hardest, and I know she would like to take the challange) and care of magical creatures cuz of Harrry, Ron and Hagrid. The other ones I dont think were nessesary. Then again, if she didnt take so many classes, Ron + Harry and Hermoine wouldnt have their issue of trust. I could tell Ron who hated Hermione that year didnt trust her cuz of the time turner. Lastly, how would they save Sirus???? That stups me!

by **Nobby** » Thursday 19 February 2004 12:06:50pm

they would have found a way to save sirius. they always do

by **Aberforth** » Thursday 19 February 2004 5:24:30pm

Marcus Baker wrote: I could tell Ron who hated Hermione that year didnt trust her cuz of the time turner.

He may not have understood what was going on with her but I doubt that Ron hated Hermy.

by **Loony_4_Snape** » Thursday 26 February 2004 4:56:27pm

Aberforth wrote:
Marcus Baker wrote: I could tell Ron who hated Hermione that year didnt trust her cuz of the time turner.

He may not have understood what was going on with her but I doubt that Ron hated Hermy.

tru, he is just insecure about Hermy,, i guess he doesn't relise he like her!
remember when he kept going at her about Krum...

by **slava** » Saturday 6 March 2004 3:59:32pm

i dont think thet ron wil hate her ever they are the best frends.

by **Evil Wizard Petting Zoo** » Monday 22 March 2004 4:02:21am

wow if that hadnt happened, sirius woulda been worse than dead.

by **zledm007** » Wednesday 23 June 2004 6:40:11am

it owuld have changed the plots of the fourth and fifth books dramatically. While Sirius may have played small roles in both the books, moreso the fourth than the fifth, he was without-a-doubt intracal to the plot. Without him, things would have been drastically different, but right now i'm too tired to think of exactly how. How bout we start a lost of all the things that would've been different w/out Sirius in books 4 and 5. then we'll try to "re-write" the stories w/out him. what do you say?

by **sweetassugar555** » Monday 18 July 2005 7:31:30pm

it would have changed the book dramatically

by **digby202** » Saturday 23 July 2005 1:52:21pm

Sirius didnt play a big role in book 4, other than to convince the dursleys to let harry go to QWC. Book 5 though, no Number 12 Grimmuald Place for a start

by **Mrs. Luca Black** » Saturday 13 August 2005 5:01:56am

Bah to you all for doubting that Dumbledore couldn't have saved Sirius anyway.

Buckbeak, however, would most likely not have been saved.

Oh, and Hermione would have done even better on her Charms exam (the cheering charms) and she would be even more smug about her grades.

Broomsticks And Owls

What if Hermione had never...

What if Hermione had never...

Who is online