Broomsticks And Owls

by **Simatra** » Tuesday 23 January 2007 11:00:35pm

Well what are YOU doing? :lol:

But I agree! :lol:

I'm sorry, couldn't resist... :lol:

by **GodrictheGriffon** » Tuesday 23 January 2007 11:19:28pm

I get it Alexandra. I'm not sure if this point's already been argued but he should have seen them since 2nd year because he still saw them after Cedric's death even though his eyes were closed and he probably doesn't remember his parents actually die. Do thestrals pertain to animals other than humans? What about horcruxes? If so, than even if he couldn't see them after his parents deaths, he could see them after COS.

by **lovegood63** » Wednesday 24 January 2007 10:48:22pm

Well well well.... Sorry then...oo and what are you? are you a moderator? because i have never met you b4. I am lovegood, nice to meet u. :lol:

o wait thats off topic :razz:

nice talking to ya :lol:

by **GodrictheGriffon** » Thursday 25 January 2007 10:14:39pm

Liar!

You've met me before! We talk about football!

by **Simatra** » Thursday 25 January 2007 10:36:59pm

I don't think she was refering to you...

by **GodrictheGriffon** » Thursday 25 January 2007 10:49:15pm

Who was she reffering to.?

by **lovegood63** » Thursday 25 January 2007 10:53:17pm

I dunno why don't you ask her?

by **Phoenix in the Ashes** » Friday 26 January 2007 5:26:25am

On topic.

I don't think you shuold be able ot see thestrals after watching the destruction of a horcrux - yes, it's a piece of a soul, but you are not witnessing the death of an entire complete person - that person is still alive. Yes, you're witnessing a death. But only the death of part of someone - you could just as easily argue the point as if someone had their limbs aputated - and you can't see thestrals for that either I imagine.

The person is still alive.

by **GodrictheGriffon** » Friday 26 January 2007 9:42:28pm

But what about non-humans? :-?

by **Phoenix in the Ashes** » Friday 26 January 2007 11:54:14pm

I doubt you could see a thestral after watching your pet rabbit die, but who knows.

by **GodrictheGriffon** » Saturday 27 January 2007 1:44:46am

I wonder if they can see them.

by **Alexandra** » Thursday 1 February 2007 11:13:03pm

We all knew that it was off topic but sometimes you just can't avoid it. This is not the first time something like that happened. :-?

OK, back on topic: he saw his parents death and he saw Sedric dying so he could have seen thestrals and it would be much better if she finnished book with Harry seeing thestrals. All books are about mysteries...

by **GodrictheGriffon** » Friday 2 February 2007 12:02:55am

C, Alex. you spell Cedric witha C.

by **Simatra** » Friday 2 February 2007 7:28:55pm

she's right, I wasn't going to mention it...

So,I thought we cleared this subject up? :-?

by **Alexandra** » Wednesday 14 February 2007 11:02:35pm

OK, sorry. :oops:

Broomsticks And Owls

Thestrals in POA

Who is online