Broomsticks And Owls

by **Person1** » Monday 15 August 2005 5:42:08pm

An excuse more than less.

Just a thought

by **Snow_Crystal** » Monday 15 August 2005 5:47:53pm

I agree. At the moment, I think S is upsetting a lot of people.

by **Salazar Slytherin** » Monday 15 August 2005 5:50:28pm

how am i upsetting people? by debating over a part of a book that i found interesting? i never knew this to be upsetting i somehow thought that the forums were for debating the books.

An excuse more than less.

Just a thought <== now that was not needed i had already ended the argument and apologized a reopining of it was not needed

by **Snow_Crystal** » Monday 15 August 2005 5:53:24pm

Enough!

by **Salazar Slytherin** » Monday 15 August 2005 5:55:32pm

which would be what i just said when i told him please dont reopen the argument.. will a mod please close down this thread.. dang and it could have been a sucessful good viewed thread

by **Snow_Crystal** » Monday 15 August 2005 5:58:28pm

Yes agreed, that was on another feed but it should happen here as well

by **Mrs. Luca Black** » Monday 15 August 2005 6:19:57pm

Salazar Slytherin wrote:which would be what i just said when i told him please dont reopen the argument.. will a mod please close down this thread.. dang and it could have been a sucessful good viewed thread

How about you try being responsible for your own actions and stop replying and thus continuing the arguement. Don't bother the mods with petty things that simple self control could handle.

by **SunsetG|rl** » Monday 15 August 2005 8:47:08pm

Mrs. Luca Black wrote:The house elves inside Hogwarts would not be used to spy on anyone in the Order or do evil deeds because they are the property of the Headmaster/mistress. Beyond that, they all seem happy with their position and are treated very fairly, so there is no reason for them to disobey (Dobby and Kreacher were miserable).

I agree with Sunset|Girl; they need to apparate in the castle because otherwise their jobs couldn't get done. The system works and there is no reason for it to be changed.

I also agree with whoever said that most wizards are too proud to have house elves do work they should do (spying, killing, etc).

i was thinking first that wht if they sent other house elves in hogwarts to do evil thnigs? not necesarily the ones working in the schools. but then i think that there must be a way to stop houseelves from the outside to aparate inside.

and it's SunsetG|rl not Sunset|Girl...but no problem .... mistakes happen

and i said both things....

and by the way...why are you having this argument...wouldn't it be nice if we all got along? just dreamin'

by **Fantasy girl** » Monday 15 August 2005 9:06:46pm

i believe that the house elves wouldn't be used,
1. they can resist an order, Dobby
2. not all house elves are under the control f evil masters.
3. there re many houseelves in hogwarts alone, didn't nick say the largest number in any dwelling in great britian

by **SunsetG|rl** » Monday 15 August 2005 9:23:17pm

i don't really understood what you ment by " they can resist an order, Dobby" could you please explain?
and by the fact that not all house elves are in control of evil masters. i thnik one, if ordered can do enough damage for once. even if he is caught after that and sent to elves prison or something.

by **Fantasy girl** » Monday 15 August 2005 9:36:33pm

i meant that they can resist an orer, Example dobby

by **Person1** » Monday 15 August 2005 9:40:13pm

I think like there are laws set by the MoM, there are likely elf-laws, like that if one is given clothing, he is free, ect..

Ps: wow, thats confusing w. both the same avatars :circling:

by **SunsetG|rl** » Monday 15 August 2005 9:41:56pm

ah...oki...but when did he actually resist an order? i thought that was imposible for a house elf...could you please refresh my memory (never ment to be rude...sry if u find me annoing)

and about the avatar..i'm still working on a new one...but i just can seem to find the right pictue...i mean i have one...the one i use on all forums and stuff...but it's too big...i could use some help with it...cause i totaly get lost in paint shops and so on...

by **Person1** » Monday 15 August 2005 9:46:32pm

Well, Dobby helped Harry, just against orders, and for that...he hurt himself...wierd laws..

by **Fantasy girl** » Monday 15 August 2005 9:52:46pm

thanks Person 1 you took the words right out of my mouth, well keyboard.

and sunset girl its okay if you have the same avatar, it took me a while to find the right one too

Broomsticks And Owls

APPARITTION PROBLEM

Who is online