RAB THE OTHER SIDE OF THE STORY

[inaya]

Since everyone is going on and on about RAB is Regulus black, did anyone actually think for a second or doubt that it may just not be him rather it may be someone else, JKR is fooling you lot into thinking its Regulus Black, don’t you lot see, how can you fall in to her little trap of thinking. I was looking at the book 6 last night and got up to the page, where Slughorn sends an invitation to Harry and Neville, right well as I read the note it said at the end of the note H.E.F Slughorn now if you compare that to R.A.B the only thing missing is the last name, how about we put it this way, this person RAB gets the locket and destroys the Horcruxe, and puts in a fake one and then writes the note to Voldemort but instead of putting his last name he puts his first three initials.

Everyone is widely known by their last name like H.E.F Slughorn, A.P.W.B Dumbledore, etc. how about this RAB put his first initials only because for voldy to know and no one else, how about is if it’s the case that RAB maybe someone we don’t know yet, someone that maybe dead or someone that is still alive, although a Horcruxe takes the life of the person that destroys it, Harry and Dumbledore still lived, how about if that RAB is still alive to this very day.

Now I know you lot might be saying what in the world she just proved that its him Regulus Black and now she says he isn’t, there is always a two side of an argument, the term dark lord can be used by death eaters, how about we say it can be used by others as well, Kreacher uses it, Dobby does and other various characters.

It may also get to help that Trelawney may know who might be RAB; like JKR said we get to find out more about a character who we met but not officially, how about that it may be the character that made Harry’s prophecy, professor Trelawney. She may get to know who he is or get a hint from her brilliant set of cards. Her predictions are very accurate at times and I get that feeling she may know some kind of information who RAB may or might be.

But then there is the character called Shaklebolt, we haven’t met him officially, all we get to know is that he is just an auror and a member of the order of the phoenix, how about we say he is someone more then it meets the eye, he may know who RAB is or how about we say that he maybe RAB. Now why would an auror highly skilled like him join up with the order of the phoenix, even though it’s explained that they need auror in the ministry because voldy would have death eaters. He doesn’t do or say pretty much always quiet, listening to others objection, but how about I say this there is always some kind of a deep secret to the person who is quiet. Why would someone like him join up the order of the phoenix after all them years, where was he when voldy was in power. Does he contain some kind of a secret that will be revealed in the next book?

[Prof.M.McGonagall]

I had thought that RAB might not be regulus black ... but all evidence say it's him... but then again, jk rowling can produce a trap ....

[Snow_Crystal]

I think she said in her interview after the book came out that Regulas would be a good guess. Have a read at www.mugglenet.com

[Chimera]

It fits with the heavy locket in Grimmauld Place.