Broomsticks And Owls

by **Holly Golightly** » Friday 9 May 2003 4:30:20pm

I just thought of something...

What if the reason Snape is always harping on at Harry for being 'out of bounds' is because he's genuinely concerned for the boy? As in, he wants to make sure that he doesnt' go where he's not supposed to and get him self hurt/killed???

What thinks???

by **Neo** » Saturday 10 May 2003 6:07:24am

I'm not sure, in that case why he wants Harry to expelled (maybe he acts like Dobby, but I don't think so)

by **Holly Golightly** » Saturday 10 May 2003 8:13:40am

oh, I gorgot about hte expelling thing!!!

No, wait, maybe he wants him expelled to that Harry wont' be around magic and people who want to harm him???

Nah, that's just lame actually!

by **Scellanis** » Saturday 10 May 2003 2:54:09pm

how do you know he doesnt purposely keep threatening to expell to scare Harry because Snape knows that Dumbledore would never actually expell Harry but that Harry doesnt know this so the threats may scare him into obeying rules....

by **Holly Golightly** » Saturday 10 May 2003 3:45:14pm

oooohhhh, that;s good!
That's really good Sonkem!!!

After all, we know that Snape is a very deviuos person!
I like it alot!

by **Mistress Siana** » Sunday 11 May 2003 1:39:55am

But if his constant threats keep on having no consequences, they will lose their effect and Snape thus will lose much of his authority.

by **Neo** » Sunday 11 May 2003 6:24:11am

Yeah, I mean Snape even told Fudge about it. And if he keeps threatening and never achieving something he will lose power an intimidation toward Harry.

by **Scellanis** » Sunday 11 May 2003 10:46:23am

he will lose that anyway as harry grows up

by **Neo** » Monday 12 May 2003 4:25:45am

I'm not sure, if Snape know how to play it, he could make it a last a lot. Iit is just like DD won't lose admiration from Harry. Snape won't lose the fear Harry has for him, but maybe he will know how to control it.

by **Holly Golightly** » Monday 12 May 2003 7:59:59am

After all, Snape has been threatening and intimidating Harry for the past 4 yrs... and it's still working!!! Maybe he will jsut stand up for himself alittle more... like he did with the mud-throwing incident???

by **Neo** » Tuesday 13 May 2003 5:45:54am

At least in the time Harry will be a student he will have some fear to Snape, but his attitude could try demonstrate the opposite as Harry gets more mature.

by **Holly Golightly** » Tuesday 13 May 2003 9:23:47am

But JK is going to stop writing about Harry when he finishes at Hogwarts, no? So really, nothing happens after that point, so how can we tell how Harry and Sanape will interact???

:???:

by **Neo** » Wednesday 14 May 2003 3:24:11am

Well I heard the last chapter was going to explain what happens to each of the survivors; so maybe there we can know in case both are alive.

by **Holly Golightly** » Wednesday 14 May 2003 8:45:58am

uhhh, I think that Snape might die inthe end... saving Harry's life, and repaying hte life debt to james...

It just seems like the thing to do???

HEHEHE!

by **Neo** » Thursday 15 May 2003 5:34:31am

But Snape has already done that, in SS.

I think he will die, but not saving Harry.

Broomsticks And Owls

Severus Snape

Who is online