Moderators: Nightcrawler, Scarlet Lioness, FawkesthePhoenix, Lone_Buck, paintballdecoy
Athena wrote:Fluffy, as far as who you're saying will be on the team, are you pulling from any past experience that would show they would, or just pulling names out of a hat? Dean has never shown any inclination to play quidditch. He keeps the soccer poster up because they're his team, and he even stands by them when he's made fun of for the poster with no moving people. His talent so far lies in art. So.....??
I agree. I think the only reason Harry will be able to get into NEWT potions is because McGonagall will pull strings, eventhough Harry said he did a lot better on his OWL without Snape there. I don't think he achieved an Outstanding.McGonagall would be one BAD teacher if she tells Harry she'll help him reach his dream and then doesn't just because Umbridge isn't around anymore. I would lose a LOT of respect for her as a teacher and a mentor.
Athena wrote:McGonagall would be one BAD teacher if she tells Harry she'll help him reach his dream and then doesn't just because Umbridge isn't around anymore. I would lose a LOT of respect for her as a teacher and a mentor.
Athena Appleton wrote:wonderful... ummm... you're making up characters. Great for fan fiction, but doesn't hold up in theories.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest